Precedents can help us understand this unprecedented crisis
- Courriel
-
Signet
-
Imprimer
First published in The Star on April 14, 2020
Authors:
Dimitry Anastakis is the Wilson-Currie Chair in Canadian Business History at the Rotman School of Management, University of Toronto.
Laurence B. Mussio is author of the newly released two-volume history Whom Fortune Favours: The Bank of Montreal and the Rise of North American Finance.
When disaster strikes, business and economic historians are asked to compare what they study with what everybody is experiencing. When a massive catastrophe strikes, like our current pandemic, the power of the unprecedented seems to leave historical analogies in the dust.
This crisis looks unprecedented because it really is. Combine a global pandemic with a global economy that has been put into an induced coma. Playbooks in both government and enterprise are shredded as executive committees meet over Zoom and figure out what to do next.
In this hurricane, can a long-run perspective provide any guidance in the face of this extraordinary moment?
The answer is yes, but it’s complicated.
The fact is that politicians and economic decision-makers are already using precedent. They are using their understanding of what worked and what didn’t in the past in a hundred ways every day. “What did we do in 2008?” is a popular question, at least in financial institutions. Trembling before the market meltdowns few have ever seen, advisers fall back on citing historical precedent in market cycles to reassure investors.
So, a paradox: in unprecedented times, precedent is the starting point. In our own research, time and again we see the following: when businesspeople and politicians are faced with something new or unexpected, they often see reflections of past actors and actions – whether or not the analogies fit.
In Hall of Mirrors, Barry Eichengreen writes about policymakers “profoundly informed by the received wisdom of the mistakes of their predecessors.” In Europe, in 2011 the German-dominated European Central Bank raised interest rates, haunted by the ghost of historical hyperinflation, and ignited another recession. The power of those implied “lessons of history” led them to create new challenges.
So, precedent should come with a warning label. Yet there are many possible insights from our collective past that we can learn from. As business historians, let’s explore five main insights.
First, to the most obvious: the economy will eventually bounce back. Pent-up consumer demand and a positive swing in the business cycle made the post-pandemic 1920s roar. The same scenario happened after 1945, only bigger. Eventually, in six months or a year, people will need to buy cars and have haircuts, and the deep economic downturn we face will subside. Results may vary.
Second, we often hear we are “at war.” Wartime emergency fast-forwards historical processes.
In the reconstruction, look for increased pressures for a revised and updated social contract between citizens and governments. This will be different from the post-Second World War Veteran’s Charter and welfare programs, which privileged male breadwinners and continued close business-government relationships. The reconstruction may result in a willingness to address questions of inequality that have shaped recent public discourse around taxation and wealth.
Third, and connected to a revised social contract, are concerns around deficit spending and debt. How do we pay for this massive intervention? Again, our collective experience suggests massive deficits are eventually tamed by prosperity and increased taxation.
Expect inflation to return.
Fourth, we are witnessing a vast expansion of state power that may not soon recede. Governments are re-emerging as the defining actor in both economic and social terms. The new era’s opening scene is already upon us in the form of the COVID-19 Emergency Response Act (in Canada and the CARES act in the U.S.), which authorizes truly colossal increases in government spending.
Just as there are no atheists in foxholes, there seem to be no austerity advocates in the face of pandemic – another echo of past crises. Once governments acquire power, they are loathe to relinquish it. Financial institutions and large enterprises take note.
Finally, these developments are likely to be much more permanent than their architects claim, rolling back the frontiers of neoliberalism. Coronavirus will succeed where the Great Financial Crisis failed in dismantling the market-friendly, elite consensus that has dominated discourse since the 1970s.
History is not a predictive mechanism. The long-run experience does not easily divulge its insights. It’s seldom straightforward. Nobody wants to play the role of André Maginot and prepare for the last war, not the one to come. Each crisis is different.
Moreover, the debates often have a recurring pattern, but identifying those patterns and connecting the dots demands a deft hand. Remember: what worked, what didn’t (and why), and how did we get here are three good questions that may not have an easy answer.
But your company’s or your country’s experience may have something to say about each. Then you can ask “what’s different?” and play the hand dealt to you.
Precedents can help us understand this unprecedented crisis
Docteur en histoire, auteur et conseiller spécial du bureau du chef de la direction
Laurence B. Mussio est docteur en histoire, auteur, chercheur, professeur d’université, conseiller en communication stratégique et un commentate…
Laurence B. Mussio est docteur en histoire, auteur, chercheur, professeur d’université, conseiller en communication stratégique et un commentate…
VOIR LE PROFIL COMPLET- Temps de lecture
- Écouter Arrêter
- Agrandir | Réduire le texte
First published in The Star on April 14, 2020
Authors:
Dimitry Anastakis is the Wilson-Currie Chair in Canadian Business History at the Rotman School of Management, University of Toronto.
Laurence B. Mussio is author of the newly released two-volume history Whom Fortune Favours: The Bank of Montreal and the Rise of North American Finance.
When disaster strikes, business and economic historians are asked to compare what they study with what everybody is experiencing. When a massive catastrophe strikes, like our current pandemic, the power of the unprecedented seems to leave historical analogies in the dust.
This crisis looks unprecedented because it really is. Combine a global pandemic with a global economy that has been put into an induced coma. Playbooks in both government and enterprise are shredded as executive committees meet over Zoom and figure out what to do next.
In this hurricane, can a long-run perspective provide any guidance in the face of this extraordinary moment?
The answer is yes, but it’s complicated.
The fact is that politicians and economic decision-makers are already using precedent. They are using their understanding of what worked and what didn’t in the past in a hundred ways every day. “What did we do in 2008?” is a popular question, at least in financial institutions. Trembling before the market meltdowns few have ever seen, advisers fall back on citing historical precedent in market cycles to reassure investors.
So, a paradox: in unprecedented times, precedent is the starting point. In our own research, time and again we see the following: when businesspeople and politicians are faced with something new or unexpected, they often see reflections of past actors and actions – whether or not the analogies fit.
In Hall of Mirrors, Barry Eichengreen writes about policymakers “profoundly informed by the received wisdom of the mistakes of their predecessors.” In Europe, in 2011 the German-dominated European Central Bank raised interest rates, haunted by the ghost of historical hyperinflation, and ignited another recession. The power of those implied “lessons of history” led them to create new challenges.
So, precedent should come with a warning label. Yet there are many possible insights from our collective past that we can learn from. As business historians, let’s explore five main insights.
First, to the most obvious: the economy will eventually bounce back. Pent-up consumer demand and a positive swing in the business cycle made the post-pandemic 1920s roar. The same scenario happened after 1945, only bigger. Eventually, in six months or a year, people will need to buy cars and have haircuts, and the deep economic downturn we face will subside. Results may vary.
Second, we often hear we are “at war.” Wartime emergency fast-forwards historical processes.
In the reconstruction, look for increased pressures for a revised and updated social contract between citizens and governments. This will be different from the post-Second World War Veteran’s Charter and welfare programs, which privileged male breadwinners and continued close business-government relationships. The reconstruction may result in a willingness to address questions of inequality that have shaped recent public discourse around taxation and wealth.
Third, and connected to a revised social contract, are concerns around deficit spending and debt. How do we pay for this massive intervention? Again, our collective experience suggests massive deficits are eventually tamed by prosperity and increased taxation.
Expect inflation to return.
Fourth, we are witnessing a vast expansion of state power that may not soon recede. Governments are re-emerging as the defining actor in both economic and social terms. The new era’s opening scene is already upon us in the form of the COVID-19 Emergency Response Act (in Canada and the CARES act in the U.S.), which authorizes truly colossal increases in government spending.
Just as there are no atheists in foxholes, there seem to be no austerity advocates in the face of pandemic – another echo of past crises. Once governments acquire power, they are loathe to relinquish it. Financial institutions and large enterprises take note.
Finally, these developments are likely to be much more permanent than their architects claim, rolling back the frontiers of neoliberalism. Coronavirus will succeed where the Great Financial Crisis failed in dismantling the market-friendly, elite consensus that has dominated discourse since the 1970s.
History is not a predictive mechanism. The long-run experience does not easily divulge its insights. It’s seldom straightforward. Nobody wants to play the role of André Maginot and prepare for the last war, not the one to come. Each crisis is different.
Moreover, the debates often have a recurring pattern, but identifying those patterns and connecting the dots demands a deft hand. Remember: what worked, what didn’t (and why), and how did we get here are three good questions that may not have an easy answer.
But your company’s or your country’s experience may have something to say about each. Then you can ask “what’s different?” and play the hand dealt to you.
Autre contenu intéressant
IN Tune: The AI + Data Center Build Out: Sustainability Impacts, Second Order Beneficiaries
Le partenariat États-Unis-Canada: perspectives économiques en Amérique du Nord
Alimentation, agriculture, engrais et facteurs ESG – thèmes abordés lors de la 19e conférence annuelle sur les marchés agricoles de BMO : recherche sur les actions de BMO
IN Tune: Food, Ag, Fertilizer, and ESG From BMO’s 19th Annual Farm to Market Conference
Budget fédéral de 2024 : Hausse de l’impôt sur les gains en capital; quelques pépites pour les entrepreneurs
Attracting More Generalist Investors in North America to the Oil and Gas Industry
Le sommet inaugural de BMO sur l’obésité est axé sur les thérapies et la lutte contre une épidémie croissante
BMO Blue Book: U.S. Economy is Resilient but Predicted to Slow in Early 2024
The Age of Transparency: Companies Poised to Benefit as Reporting Rules Tighten
Breaking Down the Food Waste Problem: Big Inefficiencies = Big Opportunity
ESG Thoughts of the Week from BMO Equity Research: Wildfire Risk, CAT Losses Increasing
Les spécialistes de BMO à notre 18e Conférence annuelle sur les marchés agricoles
Alimentation, agriculture, engrais et critères ESG lors de la 18e Conférence annuelle sur les marchés agricoles de BMO
BMO Equity Research Hosts Voluntary Carbon Market Discussion at BNEF
North American Outlook: Incertitude : tout, partout et tout à la fois
La transition énergétique nécessitera la collaboration entre les minières et les utilisateurs finaux
Rapport spécial des Études économiques de BMO : Un trio de facteurs préoccupants
Stratégie de placement nord-américaine : perspectives du marché américain 2023
Meilleurs classements pour l'équipe Macrostratégies, Titres à revenu fixe, devises et marchandises de BMO Marchés des capitaux dans un sondage effectué auprès des clients investisseurs institutionnels
Inflation, taux d’intérêt et économie : que nous réserve l’avenir?
Article d’opinion : Les entreprises et les organismes communautaires doivent unir leurs efforts pour combattre la pauvreté
Problèmes de la chaîne d’approvisionnement : le bien-être des fournisseurs au cœur des préoccupations
Capital-investissement : Déployer les capitaux dans la nouvelle normalité
Dépenses budgétaires fédérales : une vaguelette plutôt qu’une vague
EXERCICES 2022 ET 2023 : Mettre de l’ordre dans « ses affaires »
The Market Transition from COVID-19 has Begun: Belski to BMO Metals and Mining Conference
L’état actuel et futur de la chaîne d’approvisionnement mondiale
Les changements radicaux causés par le variant Omicron et la pandémie – Mise à jour sur la situation sanitaire et la biopharmaceutique
Le variant Omicron – Perspectives sur la santé et les marchés
Le meilleur des deux mondes : L’avenir du travail sur les marchés des capitaux
Des spécialistes de BMO discutent des résultats des élections canadiennes
De formidables nouveaux facteurs donnent les moyens de croître aux activités de fusion et d’acquisition aux États-Unis
IN Tune: Food and Ag Takeaways From the Farm to Market Conference
COVID-19 : Les 100 premiers jours de Joe Biden : vers la reprise
Biggest Trends in Food and Ag, From ESG to Inflation to the Supply Chain
One Year Later: Lessons Learned in the Food Supply Chain
Infonuagique, données et zéro confiance : voilà les aspects de la cybersécurité privilégiés par les investisseurs de capital de risque
Banques centrales, changements climatiques et leadership : Forum annuel destiné aux femmes œuvrant dans le secteur des titres à revenu fixe, devises et produits de base
L’appétit croissant pour l’investissement dans un but précis dans les valeurs à revenu fixe par Magali Gable
BMO annonce un don de 250 000 $ aux organisations qui soutiennent les efforts de secours d'urgence mondiale contre la COVID-19
Budget fédéral de 2021 : Dépenser en vue de l’immunité et au-delà
Le grand saut dans la dette – Comment les détaillants ont emprunté pour rester à flot durant la COVID
Le Canada pourrait connaître son plus fort rebond économique en un demi-siècle, mais il faut viser une reprise équitable, d’après une table ronde
IN Tune: Commodity Pointers From China's Big Policy Meeting
Mise à jour à l’intention de nos clients : Une année d’adversité, de résilience et de croissance
Diriger avec résilience : Points saillants du Forum à l’intention des femmes dirigeantes de BMO
Conversation avec Ian Bremmer : La pandémie et le paysage géopolitique en évolution
IN Tune: ESG Performance in the Canadian Real Estate Industry
Gestion des flux de trésorerie de la prochaine génération : votre feuille de route de la transformation numérique
La Pandémie, D’aujourd’hui A Demain - Entretiens avec les spécialistes
Perspectives des marchés américain et canadien 2021 – Spécialistes de BMO
The Evolution of Corporate Purpose and Pandemic: The Great Accelerator
Premiers résultats des élections américaines : Ce que nous savons
L’année 2020 façonnera toute une génération - Entretiens avec les spécialistes
La vie de tous les jours a changé - Entretiens avec les spécialistes
Episode 25: Achieving Sustainability In The Food Production System
L’évolution du processus démocratique - Entretiens avec les spécialistes
La transformation du milieu de travail - Entretiens avec les spécialistes
La COVID 19 souligne une évolution des systèmes de négociation électroniques
L’essor de l’apprentissage virtuel - Entretiens avec les spécialistes
Comment optimiser les liquidités dans un contexte incertain
Faire le point sur la situation avec vos gens - Entretiens avec les spécialistes
Entretien avec Jared Diamond : la COVID-19, une crise prometteuse
Changer les perceptions à propos du secteur canadien du pétrole et du gaz
Résurgence de l’épidémie de COVID-19 aux États-Unis : Dr Eric Feigl-Ding, épidémiologiste
The E-commerce and CPG Implications of COVID-19
Le chemin du rétablissement de la demande mondiale pétrolière et gazière sera long : Rystad Energy
Episode 16: Covid-19 Implications and ESG Funds with Jon Hale
Sonder les profondeurs de la récession imputable à la COVID-19
Inside Stories: Gabriela Herman – Professional Photographer
Effets de la crise de la COVID-19 sur le secteur des technologies et des logiciels
Une mise à jour destinée à nos clients : Travailler pendant et après la pandémie
Données critiques – Des tests, des tests, et encore plus de tests
Technology and Software: How COVID Will Change Remote Work Forever
Inside Stories: Both a Major League Athlete and a Stay-at-Home Dad
Résultats du sondage de l’Association for Financial Professionals (AFP) sur la réaction des trésoriers à la COVID-19
Rapport spécial de BMO sur l'économie post-pandémique : combler les écarts
Leadership and Long-Run Experience in a Time of Radical Uncertainty
La COVID-19 met en lumière l’importance de solides pratiques en matière de gestion de la liquidité et de prévention de la fraude
Le pic de la pandémie de COVID-19 en vue grâce aux mesures d’atténuation
Discussion avec le chef de la direction de BMO : Comprendre les conséquences de la COVID-19
Les mesures de relance publiques ralentiront la chute, mais n’empêcheront pas la récession
Les experts de BMO s’expriment : Répercussions économiques et sociales de la COVID-19
COVID-19: Reshaping the restaurant industry, today and tomorrow
Les prochaines semaines seront déterminantes dans la lutte contre la COVID-19
Contenir la propagation de la COVID-19 – Y a-t-il des raisons d’être optimiste?
Les six grandes banques canadiennes prennent des mesures décisives pour soutenir leurs clients affectés par la COVID-19