Boom, Bust and the Echo of History: Author John D. Turner in Conversation
- Courriel
-
Signet
-
Imprimer
*Disponible en anglais seulement
“You think of the time lag between the invention of the technology and then the bubble. So, with AI, is it going to happen quite quickly? And the thing about a general-purpose technology (GPT) is you don't know it's a general-purpose technology until after the event. People at the time didn't realize that the steam engine would transform the world, or electricity, or computerization and the internet. So, we're sitting today trying to guess is this the next big thing? It might be … it might not be.” – Professor John D. Turner, co-author of the best-selling book “Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles,” and Professor of Finance and Financial History, Queen’s Business School, Queen’s University Belfast
In this episode of Markets Plus, host Dr. Laurence B. Mussio, Special Advisor to the CEO, BMO Financial Group and Chair of the Long Run Institute, sits down with Professor John D. Turner to focus on connecting the present to the past through financial cycles.
In this episode:
-
The core concepts of financial cycles
-
How historical financial cycles can inform present market decisions
-
The importance of context and the lessons learned from past booms and busts
-
The unique challenges posed by globalized finance, technology, and AI in the current financial landscape
-
How understanding history can help prepare for future economic disruptions
Listen to the ~20-minute episode.
Markets Plus is live on all major channels including Apple, and Spotify.
Start listening to our library of award-winning podcasts.
John Turner:
You think of the time lag between the invention of the technology and then the bubble. So with AI, is it going to happen quite quickly? And the thing about a general purpose technology is you don't know it's a general purpose technology until after the event. People at the time didn't realize that the steam engine was going to transform the world or electricity or computerization and the internet. So, we're sitting today trying to guess, well, is this the next big thing? It might be, it might not be.
Speaker 2:
Welcome to Markets Plus, where leading experts from across BMO discuss factors shaping the markets, economy, industry sectors, and much more. Visit bmocm.com/marketsplus for more episodes. The views expressed here are those of the participants and not those of BMO Capital Markets, its affiliates or subsidiaries.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Hello and welcome to the Markets Plus podcast presented by BMO Financial Group. I'm your host, Dr. Lawrence Mussio. I'm a special advisor to the CEO of the bank and chair of the Long Run Institute. I'm also author of Whom Fortune Favors: the Bank of Montreal and the Rise of North American Finance. Today, we're embarking on something a bit unusual, but I think insightful. We'll examine the markets through the lens of long run cycles and patterns. After all, history dissolves mystery, at least when it's done well and properly. In times of contemporary market volatility and global uncertainty, understanding these cycles is more important than ever.
Joining me is my colleague and fellow co-founder of the Long Run Institute, Professor John Turner. John is a professor of finance and financial history at Queen's University Belfast and a former dean of Queen's Business School. He's also the founder and director of the Queen's University Center for Economic History. His award-winning book, Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles, was selected as a Financial Times Economics Book of the year in 2020. He has held distinguished positions at institutions like the Bank of England and Harvard Business School. John, it's a real pleasure to have you on the show.
John Turner:
Thanks, Lawrence. It's great to be here with you.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
John, as co-founders of the Long Run Institute, we've been passionate over the last few years about uncovering how historical patterns can illuminate our understanding of financial markets, but not only for its own sake, but especially for decision makers. So, what we try to do is to connect long run trends and experiences to grand challenges facing today's businesses and governments. And your book, Boom and Bust examines financial bubbles throughout history. And I suppose the theme is eternally relevant, especially in this year of hypersensitive market conditions. So, I guess my first question would be, what inspired you to focus on this subject of financial cycles and bubbles?
John Turner:
Yeah. That's a really good question, Lawrence. As someone who's been interested in the history of finance, I've always been interested in these bubbles that took place in the past. But it was really my lived experience of actually experiencing these bubbles myself that inspire me to write the book. So, if I start, for example, in 1997, I get married, I buy a starter home, and a few years later we're going to trade up, and I see the people coming into our home to try and buy it. And you're always trying to figure out, are these people actually going to follow through? Are they going to get a mortgage? And so eventually I talk to these people and I find out they're ninjas, no income, no job. And so I ask them, "Well, how are you going to get a mortgage?" And they tell me that there are 100% mortgages and 105% mortgages available to buy the house.
So, all of a sudden my alarm bells started going off in my head. And then over the next five years, so I buy a new house, my house quadruples in value. And so here we are today sitting in 2024, my house is 50% less than it was back in 2007. So, I lived through this huge housing boom and bust in Ireland. So, that really was the thing that really inspired me to write the book. Added to that, I was in China, so connecting Ireland to China, I was in China in 2015. I was dean of our business school at Queen's University, and I was visiting alumni, and Shenzhen and Shanghai were in the middle of this huge bubble, particularly of technology stocks. And I was meeting alumni from my university, I was meeting former students and they were all super excited about how well the stock market was performing, and I was going, "Hmm, I've seen this before." And that was really when I decided I need to write a book about bubbles.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
That's amazing. And I think the housing story that you recounted in your opening remarks will very much resonate with a lot of our listeners today, so, this is a very timely conversation. And I think also one of the things that I flippantly said about history dissolving mystery, might applicable to uncovering those cycles within market volatility.
So, we do have this market volatility in housing, perhaps even in tech stocks. It just seems, especially with generative AI. So, it's crucial, I think, to recognize the patterns that have been repeated over time. And I think that can be a very powerful tool in negotiating today's financial landscape. Maybe you can comment on that a little bit on how a better appreciation of financial cycles can help us manage risk and opportunities. Because look, we're also talking about the overconfidence of markets that say, "Well, it's different this time," to coin a phrase of Rogoff and Reinhart's book. And that kind of thinking, as your story suggested, usually precedes a crisis. How can an appreciation of financial cycles help us manage those risks and opportunities?
John Turner:
So, in Boom and Bust, we look at three centuries of financial bubbles and we identify a pattern. All bubbles have what we call the bubble triangle. So, there's three sides to this bubble triangle-
Dr Laurence Mussio:
I think I've been to the bubble triangle.
John Turner:
Yeah. People have got lost in the bubble triangle. So, the bubble triangle is where we have low interest rates or easy credit conditions. That's one side of the bubble triangle. That's like the fuel.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yes.
John Turner:
Okay. Then we have the oxygen of the bubble triangle, which is the marketability. So, this is the ease with which we can buy and sell financial assets, houses. And of course there's regulatory changes that drive that. And there are technological changes that drive that. And usually during bubbles, marketability goes up. And then the third side of the bubble triangle, if you like, the heat of the bubble triangle is the speculation. During bubbles, you get a lot of amateurs coming into the market and professionals usually can work against that. But during bubbles, it's really difficult to go short the market. So, there are, what are called, short-tail constraints in markets. That's a bubble triangle. And then all bubbles, all fires, need a spark to set them of, that sets the speculators off. And we identify two sparks. One is politics, so politicians do something that sparks a bubble. The other is some radical new technology that gets speculators excited and boom, we have a bubble. So, that's the pattern that we recognize in the book. And it's called the bubble triangle.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yes. I think our listeners will be able to apply that bubble triangle to, at least, three or four discrete areas of contemporary economic life right now. We're talking about housing, we're talking about perhaps even artificial intelligence, which we'll get to in a moment. And it's fascinating to see how economic history is not just about economics. It's about regulation. It is about a political economy as well. And just thinking of technology, we have trust and antitrust, thinking about the housing that we were just talking about, that it's maybe immigration policy or let's say mortgage rules that are liberalized or restricted. And then most interestingly, what you're saying is that overconfidence and risk-taking, because you had the average punter who's trying to get into the game to make a quick buck. So, maybe talk about that a little bit more, that overconfidence and risk-taking and how it escapes the professional manager's area of competence because everybody's crowding in, so they can't control the market.
John Turner:
So, fear of missing out.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yes.
John Turner:
So, a lot of these amateur investors, whether it's buying shares, cryptocurrencies, houses, whatever it might be, there's a fear of missing out. And they see an easy buck to be made, and their friends are making money investing in these stocks, these cryptocurrencies, these houses, so they're going to do it. You also get wider social pushes that are going to result in people moving into these markets. So, famously, the housing bubble that took place in the United States, UK, Ireland, Spain in the 2000s, a lot of this is driven by the press. So, the business model of the press, the printed press especially, has changed so that they now have incentives to carry advertisements, advertising houses for sale. They have incentives to actually puff the bubble, if you like. And then you've got TV shows. Flip My House or amateurs who are buying and selling houses and making money out of it. And it looks simple, it looks straightforward. And of course, banks are willing to throw money at these amateur speculators. And that's when trouble really starts.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Interesting. Yes. Our listeners and others can really focus on, that is so applicable, especially to tech stocks. Tech stocks seems, we can maybe zoom in on that a little bit. What is your view of this massive tech investment in generative AI? Does it have the characteristics of a bubble? The promoters like Nvidia who are saying, "Look, this is Moore's Law squared." Moore's Law squared, in terms of the progress of artificial intelligence. It could be true, but my heavens, if that is true, then maybe it will be different this time or is it?
John Turner:
So, this is the million-dollar question that everyone's asking at the minute. But if we take a step back to 2020, all of a sudden during the pandemic, several months into the pandemic, we begin to see bubbles in particular asset classes. We have it in green technology stocks, we have it in the, so called, FANG stocks. So, the Facebooks, the Googles, the Apples of this world. We have it also in Tesla stocks and electric vehicle stocks. So, there's a lot of excitement during the pandemic. And why is that the case? Well, first of all, interest rates have been dropped to near zero. There's lots of money floating around. We have actually made it easy for people to buy and sell stocks because we've gamified buying and selling of stocks and cryptocurrency. So, think of Robinhood and other apps that you can access through your phone, that you can buy parts of stocks. You don't even have to buy the whole Tesla stock, you can just get a 100th of the Tesla stock.
And then during the pandemic, of course, you have lots of sporting events are closed, and so people can't gamble anymore. So, what do they do? They've got a lot of extra money because they're not out spending it at restaurants, going on holidays. They're putting it into the stock market. And that's still there to some extent. And the interest now has moved on from electric vehicle stocks. It's back into cryptocurrency, interestingly, but it's also then into AI stocks or AI adjacent stocks because a lot of the AI today, of course, is in private markets. It's not actually being traded on capital markets.
The interesting thing is the hype. So, during the Chinese bubble in 2015, if you wanted to raise capital in the market, you describe yourself as a technology company, even if you were producing wooden floors. That's what some of these companies were doing. And so you will see a lot of hype about AI. So, if I was wanting to raise capital today, AI would be the top thing I'd be telling potential investors. We're not really a company doing this, we're really an AI company. So, I would be concerned that there is a lot of hype. We don't really know if AI is going to be this radical breakthrough new technology that everyone says it's going to be.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yes.
John Turner:
It has potential, but we don't yet know.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
But John, wouldn't we also have recourse to the pattern recognition of predecessor technologies. And so technological transformations happen along a fairly predictable pattern. And so obviously there are known and unknowns. And when we talk about pattern recognition, we also have to understand where the pattern breaks. And that is exactly what you're saying is the million-dollar question, will it break? Is for example, AI, an invention of a method of invention, like the Industrial Revolution, and is it going to become a general purpose technology? But even still, there'd be dragons there as well because it's a matter of timing, is it not? So, in terms of electricity and in terms of steam power, all of those things say, "Look, you get into the market early, then you might lose your shirt." Now, what remarks might you have on those connections?
John Turner:
So, through history, we've had three general purpose technologies. So, the first one was the steam engine, so invented in 1765. It's not really widely adopted or used until the railroads are developed in the UK. And when the railroads are being developed in the 1840s, we get this huge bubble, probably the largest bubble there ever has been in history. We get hundreds of railway companies setting up and their stock prices zooming way up. And then we get this brilliant railroad network built. We get all of these railway engines. That's fantastic. But a lot of people losing money.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Exactly.
John Turner:
We have the same with electricity. So, electricity is roughly invented about the 1870s, but it's not until the 1920s that we see electricity popping up in stock markets. So, everyone knows about the Wall Street crash of 1929, but the run-up in the 1920s in the US, what was that driven by? It was driven by the electrification of factories. All of a sudden, this electricity is now being put into factories and it's really driving the productivity of US firms, but it's also driving the stock prices of these firms.
The next general purpose technology, computerization. So, 1960s. We don't get a bubble in the 1960s, but with the internet and with information communication technologies in the 1990s, we get this huge bubble in terms of, it happens in the US, it happens in Asia, it's in Germany, it's in the UK, tax stocks going through the roof and then collapsing. A lot of people, of course, lose a lot of money through this. We get an amazing sort of ICT setup across many countries that experience these bubbles. So, then the question for us today is, well, is AI going to go the same way?
And you think of the time lag between the invention of the technology and then the bubble. That's getting shorter and shorter with each of those new general purpose technologies. So, with AI, is it going to happen quite quickly? And the thing about a general purpose technology is you don't know it's a general purpose technology until after the event. People at the time didn't realize that the steam engine was going to transform the world or electricity or computerization and the internet. So, we're sitting today trying to guess, well, is this the next big thing? It might be, it might not be.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Precisely. And I think that caveat to say is it a GPT or not is very important because we're not quite there yet. Because it's already been declared as a GPT by even some very senior economists. They're saying, "Okay. This really does look like that." But history will maybe teach us to be a little bit more circumspect about declaring the next coming. The second coming. I suppose I've got one last question and that is, regulation or government policy. Where does that fit in? Because every single example that you've used has a public policy component or a regulatory component that might've worsened things or stabilized things. So, what is the role of government in this?
John Turner:
So, let's go back to the bubble triangle again. Of course, it's taken from the fire triangle in chemistry. Fires can be super destructive. And we find historically the bubbles are super destructive when banks are lending to finance the new technology or to finance whatever the bubble stocks are. So, regulation plays a super important role in making sure that we don't pour fuel on the fire, that the banks, that other financial institutions are not extending credit in imprudent ways. So, that's a super important thing.
At the same time, governments sometimes can get worried about, oh, there's a bubble. And the central bank, especially, is saying, "Okay. What should we do here?" Should we lean? In other words, push up interest rates and pop the bubble or should we just clean? In other words, after the bubbles burst, they set about cleaning up things and acting as a lender of last resort, providing some sort of support and stimulus. So, that lean versus clean is always a tension. With technology, I would always suggest clean, because if you lean into something, you could actually damage the creation of the technology and the innovation that's going to happen.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yeah. I'm completely aligned on that. I think one of the great challenges is that public policymakers need to understand that long run analysis. And I think sometimes that is so often missing. A great banker once told me that, the higher you go, the deeper context you need. And that is perhaps where we'll leave it today. John, thank you very much for sharing your insights today. I think our conversation really does highlight how understanding cycles and patterns in history can provide at least some clarity in the contemporary volatility we face in the markets.
For our listeners, I highly recommend John's book, Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles. It really is an award-winning, but also very interesting exploration of financial cycles that offer some very serious lessons for anyone interested in the markets. So, thank you all for joining us on Markets Plus. Remember, history dissolves mystery, even in markets. So, stay informed, stay engaged, and let's continue this important conversation. And so until next time, I'm Lawrence Mussio.
John Turner:
Thank you very much, Lawrence.
Speaker 2:
Thanks for listening. You can follow this podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. For more episodes, visit bmocm.com/marketsplus.
Speaker 4:
For BMO disclosures, please visit bmocm.com/podcast/disclaimer.
- Temps de lecture
- Écouter Arrêter
- Agrandir | Réduire le texte
*Disponible en anglais seulement
“You think of the time lag between the invention of the technology and then the bubble. So, with AI, is it going to happen quite quickly? And the thing about a general-purpose technology (GPT) is you don't know it's a general-purpose technology until after the event. People at the time didn't realize that the steam engine would transform the world, or electricity, or computerization and the internet. So, we're sitting today trying to guess is this the next big thing? It might be … it might not be.” – Professor John D. Turner, co-author of the best-selling book “Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles,” and Professor of Finance and Financial History, Queen’s Business School, Queen’s University Belfast
In this episode of Markets Plus, host Dr. Laurence B. Mussio, Special Advisor to the CEO, BMO Financial Group and Chair of the Long Run Institute, sits down with Professor John D. Turner to focus on connecting the present to the past through financial cycles.
In this episode:
-
The core concepts of financial cycles
-
How historical financial cycles can inform present market decisions
-
The importance of context and the lessons learned from past booms and busts
-
The unique challenges posed by globalized finance, technology, and AI in the current financial landscape
-
How understanding history can help prepare for future economic disruptions
Listen to the ~20-minute episode.
Markets Plus is live on all major channels including Apple, and Spotify.
Start listening to our library of award-winning podcasts.
John Turner:
You think of the time lag between the invention of the technology and then the bubble. So with AI, is it going to happen quite quickly? And the thing about a general purpose technology is you don't know it's a general purpose technology until after the event. People at the time didn't realize that the steam engine was going to transform the world or electricity or computerization and the internet. So, we're sitting today trying to guess, well, is this the next big thing? It might be, it might not be.
Speaker 2:
Welcome to Markets Plus, where leading experts from across BMO discuss factors shaping the markets, economy, industry sectors, and much more. Visit bmocm.com/marketsplus for more episodes. The views expressed here are those of the participants and not those of BMO Capital Markets, its affiliates or subsidiaries.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Hello and welcome to the Markets Plus podcast presented by BMO Financial Group. I'm your host, Dr. Lawrence Mussio. I'm a special advisor to the CEO of the bank and chair of the Long Run Institute. I'm also author of Whom Fortune Favors: the Bank of Montreal and the Rise of North American Finance. Today, we're embarking on something a bit unusual, but I think insightful. We'll examine the markets through the lens of long run cycles and patterns. After all, history dissolves mystery, at least when it's done well and properly. In times of contemporary market volatility and global uncertainty, understanding these cycles is more important than ever.
Joining me is my colleague and fellow co-founder of the Long Run Institute, Professor John Turner. John is a professor of finance and financial history at Queen's University Belfast and a former dean of Queen's Business School. He's also the founder and director of the Queen's University Center for Economic History. His award-winning book, Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles, was selected as a Financial Times Economics Book of the year in 2020. He has held distinguished positions at institutions like the Bank of England and Harvard Business School. John, it's a real pleasure to have you on the show.
John Turner:
Thanks, Lawrence. It's great to be here with you.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
John, as co-founders of the Long Run Institute, we've been passionate over the last few years about uncovering how historical patterns can illuminate our understanding of financial markets, but not only for its own sake, but especially for decision makers. So, what we try to do is to connect long run trends and experiences to grand challenges facing today's businesses and governments. And your book, Boom and Bust examines financial bubbles throughout history. And I suppose the theme is eternally relevant, especially in this year of hypersensitive market conditions. So, I guess my first question would be, what inspired you to focus on this subject of financial cycles and bubbles?
John Turner:
Yeah. That's a really good question, Lawrence. As someone who's been interested in the history of finance, I've always been interested in these bubbles that took place in the past. But it was really my lived experience of actually experiencing these bubbles myself that inspire me to write the book. So, if I start, for example, in 1997, I get married, I buy a starter home, and a few years later we're going to trade up, and I see the people coming into our home to try and buy it. And you're always trying to figure out, are these people actually going to follow through? Are they going to get a mortgage? And so eventually I talk to these people and I find out they're ninjas, no income, no job. And so I ask them, "Well, how are you going to get a mortgage?" And they tell me that there are 100% mortgages and 105% mortgages available to buy the house.
So, all of a sudden my alarm bells started going off in my head. And then over the next five years, so I buy a new house, my house quadruples in value. And so here we are today sitting in 2024, my house is 50% less than it was back in 2007. So, I lived through this huge housing boom and bust in Ireland. So, that really was the thing that really inspired me to write the book. Added to that, I was in China, so connecting Ireland to China, I was in China in 2015. I was dean of our business school at Queen's University, and I was visiting alumni, and Shenzhen and Shanghai were in the middle of this huge bubble, particularly of technology stocks. And I was meeting alumni from my university, I was meeting former students and they were all super excited about how well the stock market was performing, and I was going, "Hmm, I've seen this before." And that was really when I decided I need to write a book about bubbles.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
That's amazing. And I think the housing story that you recounted in your opening remarks will very much resonate with a lot of our listeners today, so, this is a very timely conversation. And I think also one of the things that I flippantly said about history dissolving mystery, might applicable to uncovering those cycles within market volatility.
So, we do have this market volatility in housing, perhaps even in tech stocks. It just seems, especially with generative AI. So, it's crucial, I think, to recognize the patterns that have been repeated over time. And I think that can be a very powerful tool in negotiating today's financial landscape. Maybe you can comment on that a little bit on how a better appreciation of financial cycles can help us manage risk and opportunities. Because look, we're also talking about the overconfidence of markets that say, "Well, it's different this time," to coin a phrase of Rogoff and Reinhart's book. And that kind of thinking, as your story suggested, usually precedes a crisis. How can an appreciation of financial cycles help us manage those risks and opportunities?
John Turner:
So, in Boom and Bust, we look at three centuries of financial bubbles and we identify a pattern. All bubbles have what we call the bubble triangle. So, there's three sides to this bubble triangle-
Dr Laurence Mussio:
I think I've been to the bubble triangle.
John Turner:
Yeah. People have got lost in the bubble triangle. So, the bubble triangle is where we have low interest rates or easy credit conditions. That's one side of the bubble triangle. That's like the fuel.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yes.
John Turner:
Okay. Then we have the oxygen of the bubble triangle, which is the marketability. So, this is the ease with which we can buy and sell financial assets, houses. And of course there's regulatory changes that drive that. And there are technological changes that drive that. And usually during bubbles, marketability goes up. And then the third side of the bubble triangle, if you like, the heat of the bubble triangle is the speculation. During bubbles, you get a lot of amateurs coming into the market and professionals usually can work against that. But during bubbles, it's really difficult to go short the market. So, there are, what are called, short-tail constraints in markets. That's a bubble triangle. And then all bubbles, all fires, need a spark to set them of, that sets the speculators off. And we identify two sparks. One is politics, so politicians do something that sparks a bubble. The other is some radical new technology that gets speculators excited and boom, we have a bubble. So, that's the pattern that we recognize in the book. And it's called the bubble triangle.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yes. I think our listeners will be able to apply that bubble triangle to, at least, three or four discrete areas of contemporary economic life right now. We're talking about housing, we're talking about perhaps even artificial intelligence, which we'll get to in a moment. And it's fascinating to see how economic history is not just about economics. It's about regulation. It is about a political economy as well. And just thinking of technology, we have trust and antitrust, thinking about the housing that we were just talking about, that it's maybe immigration policy or let's say mortgage rules that are liberalized or restricted. And then most interestingly, what you're saying is that overconfidence and risk-taking, because you had the average punter who's trying to get into the game to make a quick buck. So, maybe talk about that a little bit more, that overconfidence and risk-taking and how it escapes the professional manager's area of competence because everybody's crowding in, so they can't control the market.
John Turner:
So, fear of missing out.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yes.
John Turner:
So, a lot of these amateur investors, whether it's buying shares, cryptocurrencies, houses, whatever it might be, there's a fear of missing out. And they see an easy buck to be made, and their friends are making money investing in these stocks, these cryptocurrencies, these houses, so they're going to do it. You also get wider social pushes that are going to result in people moving into these markets. So, famously, the housing bubble that took place in the United States, UK, Ireland, Spain in the 2000s, a lot of this is driven by the press. So, the business model of the press, the printed press especially, has changed so that they now have incentives to carry advertisements, advertising houses for sale. They have incentives to actually puff the bubble, if you like. And then you've got TV shows. Flip My House or amateurs who are buying and selling houses and making money out of it. And it looks simple, it looks straightforward. And of course, banks are willing to throw money at these amateur speculators. And that's when trouble really starts.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Interesting. Yes. Our listeners and others can really focus on, that is so applicable, especially to tech stocks. Tech stocks seems, we can maybe zoom in on that a little bit. What is your view of this massive tech investment in generative AI? Does it have the characteristics of a bubble? The promoters like Nvidia who are saying, "Look, this is Moore's Law squared." Moore's Law squared, in terms of the progress of artificial intelligence. It could be true, but my heavens, if that is true, then maybe it will be different this time or is it?
John Turner:
So, this is the million-dollar question that everyone's asking at the minute. But if we take a step back to 2020, all of a sudden during the pandemic, several months into the pandemic, we begin to see bubbles in particular asset classes. We have it in green technology stocks, we have it in the, so called, FANG stocks. So, the Facebooks, the Googles, the Apples of this world. We have it also in Tesla stocks and electric vehicle stocks. So, there's a lot of excitement during the pandemic. And why is that the case? Well, first of all, interest rates have been dropped to near zero. There's lots of money floating around. We have actually made it easy for people to buy and sell stocks because we've gamified buying and selling of stocks and cryptocurrency. So, think of Robinhood and other apps that you can access through your phone, that you can buy parts of stocks. You don't even have to buy the whole Tesla stock, you can just get a 100th of the Tesla stock.
And then during the pandemic, of course, you have lots of sporting events are closed, and so people can't gamble anymore. So, what do they do? They've got a lot of extra money because they're not out spending it at restaurants, going on holidays. They're putting it into the stock market. And that's still there to some extent. And the interest now has moved on from electric vehicle stocks. It's back into cryptocurrency, interestingly, but it's also then into AI stocks or AI adjacent stocks because a lot of the AI today, of course, is in private markets. It's not actually being traded on capital markets.
The interesting thing is the hype. So, during the Chinese bubble in 2015, if you wanted to raise capital in the market, you describe yourself as a technology company, even if you were producing wooden floors. That's what some of these companies were doing. And so you will see a lot of hype about AI. So, if I was wanting to raise capital today, AI would be the top thing I'd be telling potential investors. We're not really a company doing this, we're really an AI company. So, I would be concerned that there is a lot of hype. We don't really know if AI is going to be this radical breakthrough new technology that everyone says it's going to be.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yes.
John Turner:
It has potential, but we don't yet know.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
But John, wouldn't we also have recourse to the pattern recognition of predecessor technologies. And so technological transformations happen along a fairly predictable pattern. And so obviously there are known and unknowns. And when we talk about pattern recognition, we also have to understand where the pattern breaks. And that is exactly what you're saying is the million-dollar question, will it break? Is for example, AI, an invention of a method of invention, like the Industrial Revolution, and is it going to become a general purpose technology? But even still, there'd be dragons there as well because it's a matter of timing, is it not? So, in terms of electricity and in terms of steam power, all of those things say, "Look, you get into the market early, then you might lose your shirt." Now, what remarks might you have on those connections?
John Turner:
So, through history, we've had three general purpose technologies. So, the first one was the steam engine, so invented in 1765. It's not really widely adopted or used until the railroads are developed in the UK. And when the railroads are being developed in the 1840s, we get this huge bubble, probably the largest bubble there ever has been in history. We get hundreds of railway companies setting up and their stock prices zooming way up. And then we get this brilliant railroad network built. We get all of these railway engines. That's fantastic. But a lot of people losing money.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Exactly.
John Turner:
We have the same with electricity. So, electricity is roughly invented about the 1870s, but it's not until the 1920s that we see electricity popping up in stock markets. So, everyone knows about the Wall Street crash of 1929, but the run-up in the 1920s in the US, what was that driven by? It was driven by the electrification of factories. All of a sudden, this electricity is now being put into factories and it's really driving the productivity of US firms, but it's also driving the stock prices of these firms.
The next general purpose technology, computerization. So, 1960s. We don't get a bubble in the 1960s, but with the internet and with information communication technologies in the 1990s, we get this huge bubble in terms of, it happens in the US, it happens in Asia, it's in Germany, it's in the UK, tax stocks going through the roof and then collapsing. A lot of people, of course, lose a lot of money through this. We get an amazing sort of ICT setup across many countries that experience these bubbles. So, then the question for us today is, well, is AI going to go the same way?
And you think of the time lag between the invention of the technology and then the bubble. That's getting shorter and shorter with each of those new general purpose technologies. So, with AI, is it going to happen quite quickly? And the thing about a general purpose technology is you don't know it's a general purpose technology until after the event. People at the time didn't realize that the steam engine was going to transform the world or electricity or computerization and the internet. So, we're sitting today trying to guess, well, is this the next big thing? It might be, it might not be.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Precisely. And I think that caveat to say is it a GPT or not is very important because we're not quite there yet. Because it's already been declared as a GPT by even some very senior economists. They're saying, "Okay. This really does look like that." But history will maybe teach us to be a little bit more circumspect about declaring the next coming. The second coming. I suppose I've got one last question and that is, regulation or government policy. Where does that fit in? Because every single example that you've used has a public policy component or a regulatory component that might've worsened things or stabilized things. So, what is the role of government in this?
John Turner:
So, let's go back to the bubble triangle again. Of course, it's taken from the fire triangle in chemistry. Fires can be super destructive. And we find historically the bubbles are super destructive when banks are lending to finance the new technology or to finance whatever the bubble stocks are. So, regulation plays a super important role in making sure that we don't pour fuel on the fire, that the banks, that other financial institutions are not extending credit in imprudent ways. So, that's a super important thing.
At the same time, governments sometimes can get worried about, oh, there's a bubble. And the central bank, especially, is saying, "Okay. What should we do here?" Should we lean? In other words, push up interest rates and pop the bubble or should we just clean? In other words, after the bubbles burst, they set about cleaning up things and acting as a lender of last resort, providing some sort of support and stimulus. So, that lean versus clean is always a tension. With technology, I would always suggest clean, because if you lean into something, you could actually damage the creation of the technology and the innovation that's going to happen.
Dr Laurence Mussio:
Yeah. I'm completely aligned on that. I think one of the great challenges is that public policymakers need to understand that long run analysis. And I think sometimes that is so often missing. A great banker once told me that, the higher you go, the deeper context you need. And that is perhaps where we'll leave it today. John, thank you very much for sharing your insights today. I think our conversation really does highlight how understanding cycles and patterns in history can provide at least some clarity in the contemporary volatility we face in the markets.
For our listeners, I highly recommend John's book, Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles. It really is an award-winning, but also very interesting exploration of financial cycles that offer some very serious lessons for anyone interested in the markets. So, thank you all for joining us on Markets Plus. Remember, history dissolves mystery, even in markets. So, stay informed, stay engaged, and let's continue this important conversation. And so until next time, I'm Lawrence Mussio.
John Turner:
Thank you very much, Lawrence.
Speaker 2:
Thanks for listening. You can follow this podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. For more episodes, visit bmocm.com/marketsplus.
Speaker 4:
For BMO disclosures, please visit bmocm.com/podcast/disclaimer.
Autre contenu intéressant
Building for Tomorrow: Real Estate, Construction, and Sustainability
L’aspect économique de l’élimination du carbone : un entretien avec Deep Sky
Bonnie Hammer : Les femmes en affaires devraient chercher des mentors « durs à cuire ».
Comment les entreprises peuvent s’y retrouver dans le cadre de la politique climatique du Canada
Darryl White et Ian Bremmer parlent de l’importance de la relation canado-américaine
De grands leaders sont réunis pour parler de l’avantage nord-américain au Sommet Canada–États-Unis
Comment le secteur du capital-investissement s’adapte à l’évolution de la dynamique du marché
Le partenariat États-Unis-Canada: perspectives économiques en Amérique du Nord
The Globe and Mail : Pour le Canada et ses relations commerciales avec les États-Unis, la complaisance est synonyme de somnambulisme
Le secteur du capital-investissement trouve du réconfort dans l’incertitude qui règne dans le secteur de l’agroalimentaire
L’industrie vinicole américaine a des raisons de faire preuve d’un optimisme prudent
Propos de hauts dirigeants sur l’avenir de l’agroalimentaire
Une première dans l'Ouest canadien : Avenue Living tire parti du programme d'amélioration écoénergétique de BMO pour ajouter 179 nouveaux logements locatifs dans le centre-ville d'Edmonton
Le sommet inaugural de BMO sur l’obésité est axé sur les thérapies et la lutte contre une épidémie croissante
Le coût des plans d’action des entreprises en matière de climat
Risque climatique : changements réglementaires à surveiller en 2024
Comment la NASA et IBM utilisent les données géospatiales et l’intelligence artificielle pour analyser les risques climatiques
L’obligation de publier de l’information sur les facteurs ESG est le signe d’un marché arrivé à maturité
BMO organise un financement vert pour financer le nouveau Lawson Centre for Sustainability, la construction la plus importante de Trinity College depuis un siècle
BMO se classe parmi les sociétés les plus durables d'Amérique du Nord selon les indices de durabilité Dow Jones
Le Canada a l’occasion de devenir un chef de file mondial de l’élimination du dioxyde de carbone
Selon un sondage réalisé par l'Institut pour le climat de BMO auprès des chefs d'entreprise, près de la moitié des chefs d'entreprise des États-Unis et du Canada croient que les changements climatique
Un plus grand nombre d’entreprises ont des plans pour lutter contre les changements climatiques en raison de l’importance croissante qu’ils revêtent sur leurs activités : Résultats du sondage
L’électrification constitue une occasion unique dans le cadre de la transition énergétique
Questions et réponses : comment transformer les défis économiques en possibilités
Le soutien du secteur de l’énergie dans l’atteinte des objectifs de décarbonisation du Canada
Trois idées inspirées de la Semaine du climat pour passer à l’action à la COP28
Pourquoi les entreprises doivent accélérer leurs efforts pour lutter contre les changements climatiques
Du caractère essentiel du financement pour doper les technologies d’élimination du carbone
Transformer le système alimentaire mondial au bénéfice des investisseurs et de la planète
Banco do Brasil and BMO Financial Group to Introduce First-of-its-Kind Program to Provide Sustainability-Linked Trade Loans Supporting Brazilian Exporters
BMO Donates $3 Million to GRID Alternatives to Provide Solar Energy Solutions for Low-Income Families
Comment les investissements dans le captage du carbone peuvent générer des crédits carbone
BMO fournit un nouveau produit innovant, le dépôt lié à la durabilité, à Zurn Elkay Water Solutions
Quick Listen: Michael Torrance on Empowering Your Organization to Operationalize Sustainability
BMO seule grande banque nommée au palmarès des 50 meilleures entreprises citoyennes au Canada
Un investissement rentable : la rénovation comme moyen d’atteindre la carboneutralité
Évolution du marché du carbone : ce qu’en pensent les principaux acteurs
BMO et Bell Canada mettent en œuvre un produit dérivé innovant lié à la durabilité et à des objectifs ambitieux de réduction des émissions de gaz à effet de serre
Réduction du gaspillage alimentaire : solutions, occasions et retombées
J’attends avec impatience notre 18e Conférence annuelle sur les marchés agricoles
BMO fait partie d'un groupe convoqué par l'ONU qui conseille les banques mondiales sur l'établissement d'objectifs liés à la nature
Les chefs de file de l’investissement intensifient leurs efforts en vue d’atteindre l’objectif net zéro
Favoriser les innovations technologiques pour renforcer la résilience face aux changements climatiques
BMO célèbre le Jour de la Terre avec la 3e édition annuelle du programme Des transactions qui font pousser des arbres dans ses salles des marchés mondiaux
BMO Donates $2 Million to the University of Saskatchewan to Accelerate Research Critical to the Future of Food
L’infrastructure est la clé d’un marché compétitif en Amérique du Nord – Sommet États-Unis–Canada
Le temps presse pour les solutions au changement climatique - Sommet Canada-États-Unis
North America’s Critical Minerals Advantage: Deep Dive on Community Engagement
Réchauffement climatique : le GIEC lance son dernier avertissement de la décennie
Les légendes du roc réfléchissent aux réussites et aux échecs de l’industrie minière lors de la Conférence mondiale sur les mines, métaux et minéraux critiques
Exploration des avantages de l’extraction de minéraux critiques en Amérique du Nord dans le cadre de la Conférence mondiale sur les mines, métaux et minéraux critiques
La confiance est la denrée la plus précieuse : Message de l’ICMM à la Conférence mondiale sur les mines, métaux et minéraux critiques de BMO
Explorer les risques et les possibilités associés aux notations ESG dans le secteur minier
BMO Experts at our 32nd Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference
Evolving Mining for a Sustainable Energy Transition: ICMM CEO Rohitesh Dhawan in Conversation
BMO Equity Research on BMO Radicle and the World of Carbon Credits
BMO tiendra sa 32e conférence mondiale sur le secteur des mines, des métaux et des minéraux essentiels
Public Policy and the Energy Transition: Howard Learner in Conversation
Taskforce on Nature-Related Financial Disclosure (TNFD) – A Plan for Integrating Nature into Business
Points à retenir du sondage sur le climat des petites et moyennes entreprises réalisé par l’Institut pour le climat de BMO
BMO nommée banque la plus durable d'Amérique du Nord par Corporate Knights pour la quatrième année d'affilée
Le financement vert du nucléaire : nouvelle frontière de la transition énergétique?
Assurer l’avenir des approvisionnements alimentaires : le rôle de l’Amérique du Nord
BMO s'est classé parmi les entreprises les plus durables en Amérique du Nord selon les indices de durabilité Dow Jones
Un sondage de l'Institut pour le climat de BMO révèle que les coûts et les priorités concurrentes ralentissent l'action climatique des petites et moyennes entreprises
Gérer et monétiser votre transition vers un monde carboneutre avec BMO et Radicle
BMO est l'institution financière la mieux classée selon le Global Sustainability Benchmark, le nouvel indice de référence mondial du développement durable annoncé lors de la COP 27
COP27 : Les problèmes de sécurité énergétique et l’incertitude économique ralentiront-t-ils la transition climatique?
BMO investira dans les crédits compensatoires de carbone novateurs de CarbonCure pour stocker du CO₂ de façon permanente
Financement commercial : vers le développement durable, une entreprise à la fois
RoadMap Project: An Indigenous-led Paradigm Shift for Economic Reconciliation
Une première canadienne : BMO et l'Université Concordia s'unissent pour un avenir durable grâce à un prêt innovant lié à la durabilité
Intégration des facteurs ESG dans les petites et moyennes entreprises : Conférence de Montréal
BMO entend racheter Radicle Group Inc., un chef de file des services environnementaux situé à Calgary
Investment Opportunities for a Net-Zero Economy: A Conversation at the Milken Institute Global Conference
S’ajuster face aux changements climatiques : l’Institut pour le climat de BMO
How Hope, Grit, and a Hospital Network Saved Maverix Private Capital Founder John Ruffolo
Hydrogen’s Role in the Energy Transition: Matt Fairley in Conversation
Key Takeaways on Ag, Food, Fertilizer & ESG from BMO’s Farm to Market Conference
Les risques physiques et liés à la transition auxquels font face l’alimentation et l’agriculture
Agriculture de pointe : réduire les impacts environnementaux en même temps que les coûts
Building an ESG Business Case in the Food Sector: The Food Institute
J’attends avec impatience notre 17e Conférence annuelle sur les marchés agricoles
Les prix des métaux encore loin d’une nouvelle normalité : Table ronde de BMO sur les mines
Aller de l’avant en matière de transition énergétique : Darryl White s’adresse aux gestionnaires de réserves et d’actifs mondiaux
BMO et EDC annoncent une collaboration pour présenter des solutions de financement durable aux entreprises canadiennes
Refonte au Canada pour un monde carboneutre : Conversation avec Corey Diamond d’Efficacité énergétique Canada
The Role of Hydrogen in the Energy Transition: FuelCell Energy CEO Jason Few in Conversation
BMO est fier de soutenir la première transaction d'obligations vertes du gouvernement du Canada en tant que cochef de file
Article d’opinion: Le Canada peut être un leader en matière de sécurité énergétique
Les mesures prises par le gouvernement peuvent contribuer à stimuler la construction domiciliaire afin de remédier à la pénurie de logements au Canada
Tackling Climate Change in Metals and Mining: ICMM CEO Rohitesh Dhawan in Conversation
La circulaire de sollicitation de procurations et les rapports sur la durabilité 2021 de BMO sont maintenant disponibles
Why Changing Behaviour is Key to a Low Carbon Future – Dan Barclay
BMO lance le programme Services aux entreprises à portée de main - BMO pour les entrepreneurs noirs et annonce un engagement de 100 millions de dollars en prêts pour aider les entrepreneurs noirs à dé
The Post 2020 Biodiversity Framework – A Discussion with Basile Van Havre
BMO annonce son intention de se joindre au programme Catalyst de Breakthrough Energy pour accélérer l'innovation climatique
BMO Groupe financier nommé banque la plus durable en Amérique du Nord pour la troisième année d'affilée
Using Geospatial Big Data for Climate, Finance and Sustainability
Atténuer les répercussions des changements climatiques sur les actifs physiques par la finance spatiale
BMO aide Boralex à aller Au-delà des énergies renouvelables en transformant sa facilité de crédit en un prêt lié au développement durable
Première mondiale : BMO soutient Bruce Power avec le premier cadre de financement vert du secteur nucléaire au monde
BMO se classe parmi les entreprises les plus durables au monde, selon les indices de durabilité Dow Jones
COP26 : Pourquoi les entreprises doivent assumer leur responsabilité sociale
The Future of Remote Work and Diversity in the Asset Management Industry
Changer les comportements est essentiel pour assurer un avenir à faible émission de carbone – Table ronde Milken
BMO aide Teck Resources à progresser vers ses objectifs ESG avec un prêt lié à la durabilité
Première dans le secteur des métaux et des mines en Amérique du Nord : BMO aide Sandstorm Gold Royalties à atteindre ses objectifs ESG grâce à un prêt lié à la durabilité
Éducation, emploi et autonomie économique : BMO publie Wîcihitowin ᐑᒋᐦᐃᑐᐏᐣ, son premier Rapport sur les partenariats et les progrès en matière autochtone annuel
BMO annonce un engagement de financement de 12 milliards de dollars pour le logement abordable au Canada
In support of Canada’s bid to host the headquarters of the International Sustainability Standards Board
Investing in Real Estate Sustainability with Bright Power Inc.
BMO appuie la candidature du Canada pour accueillir le siège du Conseil des normes internationales d'information sur la durabilité
BMO nommé au classement des 50 meilleures entreprises citoyennes au Canada de Corporate Knights
ESG From Farm to Fork: Doing Well by Doing Good
Banques centrales, changements climatiques et leadership : Forum annuel destiné aux femmes œuvrant dans le secteur des titres à revenu fixe, devises et produits de base
BMO met sur pied une nouvelle équipe innovatrice pour la transition énergétique
L’appétit croissant pour l’investissement dans un but précis dans les valeurs à revenu fixe par Magali Gable
BMO organise le congrès annuel mondial sur les marchés agricoles pour une 16e année consécutive
Première nord-américaine : BMO aide Gibson Energy à transformer entièrement une facilité de crédit en un prêt lié à la durabilité
Le programme Des transactions qui font pousser des arbres permettra d’en planter 100 000
Les arbres issus des métiers bénéficient d'un marché obligataire ESG solide
Understanding Biodiversity Management: Best Practices and Innovation
The Changing Face of Sustainability: tentree for a Greener Planet
La 30e conférence mondiale annuelle sur le secteur des mines et des métaux de BMO est en cours
Favoriser des résultats durables : le premier prêt vert offert au Canada
Episode 29: What 20 Years of ESG Engagement Can Teach Us About the Future
Rapport sur les perspectives de 2021 de BMO Gestion mondiale d'actifs : des jours meilleurs à venir
Episode 28: Bloomberg: Enhancing ESG Disclosure through Data-Driven Solutions
Comment Repérer L’écoblanchiment Et Trouver Un Partenaire Qui Vous Convient
BMO se classe parmi les entreprises les plus durables selon l'indice de durabilité Dow Jones - Amérique du Nord
Episode 27: Preventing The Antimicrobial Resistance Health Crisis
BMO investit dans un avenir durable grâce à un don d’un million de dollars à l’Institute for Sustainable Finance
BMO Groupe financier franchit une étape clé en faisant correspondre 100 pour cent de sa consommation d'électricité avec des énergies renouvelables
BMO Groupe financier reconnu comme l'une des sociétés les mieux gérées de manière durable au monde dans le nouveau classement du Wall Street Journal
Episode 23: TC Transcontinental – A Market Leader in Sustainable Packaging
Les possibilités de placement durables dans le monde d’après la pandémie
BMO Capital Markets to host 2020 Prescriptions for Success Healthcare Virtual Conference
Les sociétés axées sur l’efficacité énergétique peuvent maintenant réduire leurs coûts d’emprunt
BMO Groupe financier s'approvisionnera à 100 pour cent en électricité à partir d'énergies renouvelables
Episode 13: Faire face à la COVID-19 en optant pour des solutions financières durables
Épisode 09 : Le pouvoir de la collaboration en matière d'investissement ESG
Épisode 08 : La tarification des risques climatiques, avec Bob Litterman
Épisode 07 : Mobiliser les marchés des capitaux en faveur d’une finance durable
Épisode 06 : L’investissement responsable – Tendances et pratiques exemplaires canadiennes
Épisode 04 : Divulgation de renseignements relatifs à la durabilité : Utiliser le modèle de SASB
Épisode 03 : Taxonomie verte: le plan d'action pour un financement durable de l'UE
Épisode 02 : Analyser les risques climatiques pour les marchés financiers